25-year-old boyfriend asks girlfriend to post him on his Instagram for their 1-year anniversary, she refuses

Author image for JR Atkinson
JR Atkinson • Writer and Editor
Apr 19, 2026 9:00 PM EDT

Is that a reasonable request?

We would probably all be better off if we didn't attach our self-worth to social media. But that's much easier said than done. Like it or not, we live in a world where social media has so much influence on our personal lives. Even if you're not on it yourself, you feel the way it ricochets through culture. And it might even sneak in and disrupt your personal relationships. You've probably experienced this in one way or another. Maybe you're insecure about your partner's social media habits. Maybe it comes between you, even when you wish it didn't. That's what happened in this story, where a young couple was at a crossroads. A year is a pretty long milestone, if you ask me. Especially when you're young. You probably want to celebrate it when you reach it, in whatever way possible. But they hadn't crossed off some pretty essential things on the checklist. He hadn't met her friends or her parents. He wasn't even sure if anyone in her life knew that he existed. Not a great sign. But people have all sorts of weird stuff and qualifying circumstances that keep them from doing the things you might expect. Some people have baggage that may seem strange to you but normal to them. That's what was happening here, some thought. Others thought the boyfriend needed to stand up for himself and ask for more. Which is another thing that's easier said than done.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01
    A boyfriend and a girlfriend argue on the couch
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02

    Am I in the wrong for asking my gf to post me for our one year anniversary?

    So i (m25) and my gf (f25) have been going out for about a year, i haven't met her family or friends at all and she usually comes over to my place every second weekend. The argument started yesterday when i realised she's never shared a photo of the two of us and tbh i dont even know if her friends and family know i exist.
    via Particular_Ad5706
  • 03
    So yesterday i asked her if on our anniversary she could post a pic of the two of us cause i just find it wierd that shes never even mentioned me in so much as a comment, she instantly got super defensive saying she doesn't post and her page is private, which to be fair she doesn't usually but she has posted 2 things since we've been together and has other photos with friends and family exc, she's from a
    via Particular_Ad5706
  • 04
    pretty strict rich Asian family and i come from a pretty lower middle class white family which has never seemed to bother her so when i asked if that was maybe the problem she just said no shes just scared of other peoples opinions. I told her im willing to compromise with maybe initials in the her bio or a mention or something all things she said no to and the fight has gotten to the
    via Particular_Ad5706
  • 05
    point where our relationship is hanging on a thread just because of a post. Ik i was wrong in this but i did go through her phone thibking the worst that shes maybe cheating on me or hiding me from someone but still nothing and tbh i genuinely dont think she'd cheat on me.
    via Particular_Ad5706
  • 06
    Im not looking to break up over something so dumb but i genuinely just dont know what even to think but im done keeping our relationship a secret, aitah?
    via Particular_Ad5706

  • They were left wondering where they could go and what they could do. The boyfriend didn't know if he was in the wrong for wanting to be posted on his girlfriend's Instagram, or if he was right to ask for what he wanted. It's always a good idea to speak our minds, but sometimes the truth gets all jumbled up in our brains. We need some outside perspective to make sure we're making the right decision. That's what the boyfriend tried to do here. Scroll on to read exactly what happened and see what commenters had to say.

  • 07

    Commenters had theories about what was going on here.

    Agformula Sounds like you are a side dude.
    via Agformula
  • 08
    A boyfriend and a girlfriend argue on the couch
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 09
    TXaggiemom10 It sounds like she doesn't think her friends and family would approve of you. Has she met your friends and family? If she knows her parents would insist that she break up with you, this may actually be her way of preserving your relationship.
    via TXaggiemom10
  • 10
    If you see a future with this girl, tell her that her family needs to start getting used to the idea of you because you plan to be around long- term. If she still balks, ask her how she intends to date you without them knowing, or if you are just a placeholder until someone they would approve of comes along. It's a fair question at your age after one year of dating.
    via TXaggiemom10
  • 11
    HabsMan62 Well, breaking up about not wanting to post a pic would be silly. But breaking up because she is keeping you a secret from her family and friends (due to your race and socio-economic status), and is ashamed of you, is def NOT. Wake up. It sounds like she's more important to you than you are to her.
    via HabsMan62
  • 12
    Emergency-Kale... I can't see how this relationship is functional if you're a secret and visited twice a month after a year.
    via Emergency-Kale5033
  • 13
    awesomeisthena... NTA. Honestly if you haven't. met a single friend or family member in a year of dating, then it's over. She's never going to show you off because she cares more about what people think than she does about you.
    via awesomeisthename
  • 14
    TinmanOIF "I know i was wrong in this" how? You are dating for a year and she is pretending you are not. Keeping your relationship a secret means 1) she is married 2) she is cheating 3) she is "having fun" while waiting for the guy from her culture she is actually going to marry 4)
    via TinmanOIF
  • 15
    her family is extremely prejudiced/financially motivated and the knows you wont make the cut. None of the options are good. She needs to come clean or you need to walk away even though you don't want to. If she is keeping this secret what else will she?
    via TinmanOIF
  • 16
    turBo246 Personally, I wouldn't be able or willing to be in a relationship with someone who wasn't proud of being with me or who didn't want to show me off to their friends and family. Especially after being together for nearly a year.
    via turBo246
  • 17
    sierra38grandma NTAH. TBH sounds like she is hiding you from her family. They may have her promised to someone else. It's not uncommon for her culture to arrange marriages for their daughters. Or maybe she has someone else she is interested in.
    via sierra38grandma
  • 18
    surgeryboy7 I mean step back and think about the fact that you're with somebody that's ashamed of you.
    via surgeryboy7
  • 19
    Zanke95 Eh after first paragraph I am wondering are you sure you are her bf and not her sidepiece she wants to keep hidden so her bf won't find out?
    via Zanke95
  • 20
    P... NTA. She's got somebody else. She doesn't want you to know about them and she doesn't want them to know about you. Get out while you can.
    via Public-Home8535
  • 21
    ThunderKates_HO NTA- it's never fun to be someone's secret. Whatever her reasons, it's been a year, I think that's a fair time to see if she's in or out, and posting a photo is pretty low stakes in my opinion- but I'm just from a wealthy white family who doesn't give a sh about social media so admittedly this isn't my wheelhouse.
    via ThunderKates_HO
  • 22
    MonkeyWrench... NTA but also give her some more grace maybe. i come from a very similar household and my parents. didnt know about my past boyfriends until i knew our connections were well established (minimum of 6 months). revealing a
    via MonkeyWrenchX-_-
  • 23
    boyfriend is a huge thing and comes with a lot of shame thats been instilled in us, and the chances of us looking foolish can be quite high. of course, your circumstances are different given its been a year. definitely let her know you dont feel comfortable being kept a secret, even if its not
    via MonkeyWrenchX-_-
  • 24
    her intention. have you asked directly if her friends. or family know about you? have you ever spoken to any of her friends in the entirety of you relationship? if you havent, that definitely doesnt look good on her part.
    via MonkeyWrenchX-_-
  • 25
    Azure_Wolf Comprise with at least meeting her friends? Her family and the post can come later. If she won't even let you meet her friends, you need to have a serious conversation about where the relationship is going.
    via Azure_W0lf
  • 26
    CrabbiestAsp NTA but think about your relationship and if you want to be hidden from people because she is worried about their opinions more than her relationship and partner.
    via CrabbiestAsp
  • 27
    My sister stayed in a relationship where she was hidden because of 'family drama' for 2.5yrs. Ultimately she realised he was never going to go public with her because his family wouldn't accept she wasn't the same race as them, she just got dragged along and heart broken.
    via CrabbiestAsp

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

boyfriend relationship advice dating fails anniversary relationships girlfriend toxic relationship dating
Scroll Down For The Next Article